Data verified with source and date
Disputed

Disputes we track

Rules where a firm's own pages disagree with each other. Instead of hiding it, we flag it — and don't publish a number until it's resolved. The humbler read always wins.

19rules where the firm contradicts itself · across 12 firms
6rules where the disagreement is between third parties — not counted above

Why it matters: a value the firm's own pages disagree on is exactly where you can get blindsided. Affiliate sites hide it because it breaks the buy funnel. We don't.

Apex Trader Funding

Pricing · Are Legacy accounts still on sale

Firm contradicts itself
legacy-products sales page
Available Now - Limited Time, with countdown and SAVENOW pricing
source
Help centre legacy-products-overview
no longer available for purchase to anyone, as of 2026-03-01
source

What it costs you: Both are Apex pages. The sales page is treated as current and was re-checked 2026-07-27, but the help centre still contradicts it on the live site.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-28
View firm

E8 Markets

Drawdown · E8 One default max drawdown

Firm contradicts itself
Dynamic Drawdown article
6% default, customizable 4-14% at checkout
source
E8 One product article
4%
source

What it costs you: On a $100K One account this is $2,000 of drawdown room. Trade believing 6% when it is 4% and you breach $2,000 earlier than planned.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

Elite Trader Funding

News trading · Is there a news rule at all?

Firm contradicts itself
Terms of Service, effective 2026-07-13
All Elite Accounts must be flat 5 min before to 5 min after the event
source
Help-centre article, undated
ETF does not impose any restrictions or limitations on traders during major economic news events
source

What it costs you: The May ToS did NOT contain the clause: the rule was added between May and July and the FAQ was never updated. Worse, the ToS says the covered events are listed here and links to a page with no list at all - no FOMC, no CPI, no NFP. You cannot know which event breaks your account.

Open since 2026-07-28verified 2026-07-28
View firm

Elite Trader Funding

Targets & min days · Diamond Hands minimum trading days

Firm contradicts itself
Diamond Hands plan page
minimum of 5 trading days
source
Homepage plan-comparison strip
Min Trade Days: 10
source

What it costs you: Request a payout on day 6 believing it is 5, get refused, and capital stays locked another week. Both pages captured the same day.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Funded Trading Plus

Daily loss · What the daily limit is calculated on

Firm contradicts itself
Program articles
from the closed balance of the prior trading day
source
Daily-drawdown mechanics article
using the highest figure of balance OR equity, 16:59 EST reset
source

What it costs you: Decides whether a floating loss counts. Under closed-balance you can sit down unclosed and think it does not count; under balance-or-equity you already broke the rule without seeing it.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

Funded Trading Plus

Payouts · Profit-split ceiling

Firm contradicts itself
FT+ homepage
up to 100% via add-ons
source
Help-centre Profit Split article
80/20 rising to 90/10 at the 20% milestone; documents no 100% tier
source

What it costs you: You buy on the 100% headline and the only documented path stops at 90%.

Open since 2026-07-24verified 2026-07-24
View firm

FundedNext

Payouts · Does the 95% reward tier exist

Firm contradicts itself
App pricing page
95% marketed
source
Help-centre reward-share article
80% base, up to 90% via Scale-Up; no 95% tier
source

What it costs you: Secondary sources tie the 95% to a paid Lifetime 95% Reward add-on. Buying on the 95% headline means paying for something the help centre says the plan does not include.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-28
View firm

FundedNext

Targets & min days · Stellar Lite minimum trading days

Firm contradicts itself
Help-centre article 12673505
at least 5 separate trading days in each phase
source
stellar-model marketing page
2 days
source

What it costs you: Hit target on day 3 believing it is 2 and the payout does not come. Both fetched the same day.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

FXIFY

Daily loss · Instant account daily drawdown

Firm contradicts itself
FXIFY blog table
None - no daily limit
source
Instant Funded FAQ
8%, based on the previous day closing balance
source

What it costs you: The difference between having a daily limit and not having one. Believing None and trading without a brake kills the account in one session.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

FXIFY

Drawdown · 1-Phase max drawdown

Firm contradicts itself
Two rules-FAQ articles
6%
source
how-it-works marketing page
10% trailing
source

What it costs you: Four percentage points of room across the whole account. The same disagreement repeats on size ranges.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

FXIFY

Targets & min days · Lightning plan window

Firm contradicts itself
Lightning plan FAQ
5-trading-day limit to hit target
source
Homepage / how-it-works
7 days
source

What it costs you: Two days of runway on a timed target. Plan for 7 when it is 5 and you fail on the calendar, not on trading.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Instant Funding

Payouts · Payout processing time

Firm contradicts itself
Trading rules page
within 24 hours of request
source
Accounts page
most payouts processed within 48 business hours
source

What it costs you: 24 hours and 48 business hours are not the same thing: requested on a Friday, the second version can mean the following Wednesday.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

Maven Trading

News trading · Are Instant accounts exempt from the news rule?

Firm contradicts itself
Terms & Conditions
For all accounts, you may not place new trades or close existing trades within 2 minutes before or after Red Folder news events
source
FAQ and support article
The News rule does not apply to our instant accounts
source

What it costs you: The FAQ is more specific, but the T&C is the document that governs a dispute. Trading the news on an instant account trusting the FAQ leaves you with no argument when they answer with the contract.

Open since 2026-07-28verified 2026-07-28
View firm

MyFundedFutures

Consistency · Which evaluations the consistency rule covers

Firm contradicts itself
Consistency rule article
names Rapid, Flex and Pro only
source
Builder plan guides
evaluation consistency: None
source

What it costs you: Decides whether on a Builder you can make all your profit in one day, or whether that blocks the payout.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

Take Profit Trader

Consistency · How the consistency target is computed

Firm contradicts itself
Firm worked example
2x current net P/L - $3,100 x 2 = $6,200
source
The formula in the same rule
2x best day - $4,000 for a $2,000 best day
source

What it costs you: $2,200 of difference in how much must be made before withdrawing. The firm does not say which one its dashboard enforces.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

TradeDay

Targets & min days · Fast Pass minimum days

Firm contradicts itself
Pricing cards
3 days minimum
source
how-it-works and rules FAQ
No minimum on Fast Pass
source

What it costs you: It is precisely what a Fast Pass is bought for: with a 3-day minimum the product does not do what its name says.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Tradeify

News trading · Are there news rules?

Firm contradicts itself
Dedicated article, updated 2026-04-02
We do not have any rules against or guidelines around trading news events
source
Essential Trading Rules Overview
Restrictions: Specific rules around major economic events
source

What it costs you: The overview points to the full news trading policy - which is the very article saying there is no policy. A trader reading the overview waits for rules that do not exist, or the reverse.

Open since 2026-07-28verified 2026-07-28
View firm

TradeDay

Pricing · Is there an activation fee on passing

Stale page still published
Current site pricing cards
No activation fee, all plans
source
Still-live FAQ
$139 one-time setup fee each time an evaluation is passed
source

What it costs you: Probably a stale FAQ after the 2026-05 relaunch, but it is still published and still a TradeDay page. $139 per evaluation passed if that is the one that governs.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Tradeify

Daily loss · 150K daily loss limit

Stale page still published
Growth evaluation article
$3,750
source
Daily Loss Limit article
$3,000 (post-2026-03-31 value)
source

What it costs you: $750 of daily room. Purchases before 2026-03-31 keep $3,750, so both figures can be true at once for different accounts. The Growth article does not say so.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Elite Trader Funding

Pricing · Evaluation pricing

Third parties disagree
traderspost
evaluation guide pricing table
source
pipback
different figures for the same plans
source

What it costs you: Recorded as VERIFIED-SECONDARY because the reviews disagree with each other. Until captured from the firm own evaluations page, no figure is published as verified.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

FundedNext

Pricing · 200K account price

Third parties disagree
App pricing page
app figure
source
proptradingvibes
different figure for the same size
source

What it costs you: Affects the 200K size only; the rest of the table is verified against the app itself. Flagged, not resolved.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Instant Funding

Trust signals · Review score and volume

Third parties disagree
TheTrustedProp
3.1/5 across 4,676 reviews, 31% one-star
source
myprosandcons
4.0/5
source

What it costs you: Direct Trustpilot is live but blocks automated reads. Aggregator vs aggregator, not the firm against itself.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

MyFundedFutures

Trust signals · Review count

Third parties disagree
Trustpilot pagination
~15,400 implied
source
proptradingvibes
20,000+
source

What it costs you: The 4.9 is secondary: direct reads are blocked. Without a manual capture the figure is not published as verified.

Open since 2026-07-21verified 2026-07-21
View firm

The5ers

Pricing · High Stakes pricing structure

Third parties disagree
Firm X post and program pages
structure as announced by the firm
source
propfirmmatch
different structure for the same challenge
source

What it costs you: An X announcement is not product documentation. Recorded as secondary with the structure in conflict, pending a capture of the firm own pricing page.

Open since 2026-07-23verified 2026-07-23
View firm

Topstep

Payouts · First $10,000 at 100%

Third parties disagree
Topstep help centre and site
100% of your first $10,000 in lifetime profits, then 90/10
source
tradecovex, 2026-05-01
sign-ups since 2026-01-12 get flat 90/10 from the first dollar
source

What it costs you: Not Topstep against itself: a third party asserting a change the firm site does not reflect. Shown unresolved and excluded from the self-contradiction count.

Open since 2026-07-24verified 2026-07-24
View firm